Three-year-old girl missing from Kentucky since 1983 found alive after 42 years

A woman who spent more than four decades living under a different name has discovered she was allegedly abducted by her own mother as a toddler, bringing an extraordinary missing child case to a dramatic end.

Michelle Marie Newton, now 46, was just three years old when she vanished from Kentucky in April 1983. According to investigators, she was taken by her mother, Debra Newton, who claimed at the time that she was moving ahead of the family’s planned relocation to Georgia.

Michelle grew up believing she was someone else entirely. She had no idea she had been listed in the national missing child database, or that her mother had once appeared on the FBI’s ‘Top eight Most Wanted parental-kidnapping fugitives’ list. It was not until November that she was told the truth about her past.

Michelle’s father, Joseph Newton, said the last time he saw his daughter was when Debra left Kentucky with her. When he later arrived in Georgia, expecting to reunite with his family, they were gone.

A Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office press release said there was a ‘final phone call’ between 1984 and 1985 before ‘both mother and daughter vanished’. After that, all contact stopped.

Joseph launched a desperate search for his daughter. Flyers were distributed across parts of Georgia, and the case remained open for years. Debra was charged with custodial interference and added to the FBI’s parental kidnapping fugitives list.

Despite the effort, the case stalled. In 2000, Kentucky authorities dropped the investigation after losing contact with Joseph, who was described as distraught. Michelle’s name was removed from the national missing child database five years later.

The case was reopened in 2016 at the request of another family member. A grand jury re-indicted Debra in 2017, and investigators renewed their search.

The breakthrough came after a Crime Stoppers tip suggested Debra had been spotted in Florida living under a different name. According to the sheriff’s office, officers compared a recent photograph with an image from 1983 and ‘confirmed the resemblance’.

Police traced the tip to a home in The Villages, Florida. On November 24, officers arrived at the retirement community where Debra had been living as ‘Sharon Nealy’, WFTV9 reported.

As police cars pulled into the driveway, a friend joked, ‘They’re coming for you, Sharon!’ Moments later, Debra was arrested.

Officers then went to Michelle’s home to tell her the news that would change her life. ‘You’re not who you think you are. You’re a missing person. You’re Michelle Marie Newton,’ they told her. Michelle later told WLKY.

She said she was stunned to learn she had been living under a false identity her entire life. Michelle contacted Kentucky authorities herself to explain that she never knew she had been a victim. Soon after, plans were made for her to reunite with her father, who had spent 42 years searching for her.

Joseph told WLKY, ‘She’s always been in our heart. I can’t explain that moment of walking in and getting to put my arms back around my daughter. ‘I wouldn’t trade that moment for anything. It was just like seeing her when she was first born. It was like an angel.’

Michelle and Joseph were both present as Debra was arraigned on a felony charge of custodial interference. Debra was later released on bond posted by a family member, bringing one of America’s longest running parental kidnapping cases into the spotlight once again.

READ NEXT

• KFC manager ordered to pay nearly £70,000 in compensation after calling a worker ‘a slave’
• Three-year-old girl missing from Kentucky since 1983 found alive after 42 years
• Chilling Video Captures Cop Saving Distraught Woman from Bridge After Christmas
• Millie Bobby Brown’s arm injury Fuels online speculation about her marriage
• ‘What a blessing that is’ North Carolina Mom Wins $161K Lottery on Daughter’s Birthday